L.A. hoped to learn from NYC’s congestion pricing rollout. Now what?

Rush-hour traffic is clogged at the intersection of the 110 and 101 freeways.

By Ryan FonsecaStaff Writer

June 14, 2024 6:30 AM PT

Good morning. It’s Friday, June 14. Here’s what you need to know to start your day.

L.A. is still studying congestion pricing. New York’s flip flop could change the equation.
The Supreme Court rejects California man’s attempt to trademark Trump T-shirts
Nine L.A. playgrounds near life-giving coffee shops
And here’s today’s e-newspaper

New York’s congestion pricing flip-flop will make it harder to implement in L.A.

Los Angeles and New York have plenty of differences. For example L.A. has nice weather and great food. But we do share a common affliction: soul-crushing traffic.

Thankfully, there is a solution to this scourge (hint: It’s not widening freeways). To make driving less of a smog-spewing, time-sucking vortex of misery, we have to drive less. It’s that easy! 🥲

Transportation experts know how to make that happen: congestion pricing — charging people to drive on busy roads at peak times.

New York City was about to be the first North American city to implement a broad congestion pricing program, charging car drivers up to $15 daily to enter Lower Manhattan. The roughly $1 billion per year in revenue would have gone to the city’s struggling transit system.

But in a stunning reversal, Gov. Kathy Hochul ordered the program to be paused indefinitely just weeks before it was set to begin, after years of strongly supporting it.

L.A. Metro officials had hoped to see NYC’s program in action to learn from the rollout, they told me this week. Now they’re taking notes on the backlash the program faced and the backpedaling that halted it — maybe forever.

L.A.’s own congestion pricing research hasn’t come far

Traffic slows on the San Bernardino Freeway near downtown Los Angeles

Transportation officials have been studying the feasibility of congestion pricing in L.A. County since 2019.

L.A. Metro has been modeling the impacts of charging commuters to drive their cars into a few high-traffic zones:

Along the 10 Freeway between downtown L.A. and Santa Monica
On arterial streets in downtown L.A. and the many freeways that cross through it
Through windy canyon roads and freeways (mainly the 405 and 101) that link the San Fernando Valley to the L.A. Basin

Nearly five years in, that initial study is still TBD. San Francisco transportation officials paused a similar study in 2022.

“[We’re] working to put the best possible recommendations forward to our board based on our technical modeling and our public outreach,” said Mark Vallianatos, project manager for Metro’s Traffic Reduction Study.

It’s not clear when Vallianatos’ team will have those recommendations ready. They have sought more funding to further explore pricing, but state budget negotiations have delayed it.

The agency also would not disclose the prices they’ve been tinkering with, except to say they are “significantly lower than New York’s [$15] daytime price,” according to Vallianatos.

“We are looking at what’s the lowest toll we would have that would impact enough drivers to make the rest of the drivers better off,” he said.

Congestion pricing is unpopular everywhere (at first)

A recent poll showed that 63% of New Yorkers opposed the plan (though 44% of respondents said they don’t really travel to Manhattan).

Essential California readers tilted toward opposing congestion pricing when we asked last year. One sent an uncryptic “F— NO.”

“I do not have the privilege to choose what time my commute is,” wrote Elisabeth O. “Already I am paying for crazy things like gas, food and shelter. I cannot afford more expenses.”

Michael Manville, a professor of urban planning at the UCLA Luskin School of Public Affairs, has studied congestion pricing and its political acceptability for roughly 20 years. His thoughts on NYC’s congestion pricing implosion? “Shocked, but not surprised.”

“Congestion pricing has always been a very big lift,” he said, adding that it’s possible political leaders elsewhere will get more “gun-shy” about trying the policy.

“Had New York moved forward, I think it would have opened up some breathing room for Los Angeles and San Francisco to take their fairly dormant proposals and rev them back up,” he said.

Congestion pricing has cut traffic in Singapore for decades. It was unpopular in Stockholm when first implemented, but support grew to over 70%. In London, the U.S. Embassy refuses to pay over $18 million in congestion charges.

Does L.A. need to change its pitch for congestion pricing?

Studies have shown that reducing traffic can mean better air quality, higher transit ridership and safer streets. But Manville argued leaders should frame their pitch a little differently: as “a great thing for drivers.”

“The people who benefit the most are the people who pay the toll because they get to drive unimpeded,” he said. “You get something in return for your money, which is a bunch of your time back.”

Plus, congestion pricing isn’t a completely new concept in L.A., according to Manville.

“If you get on those Express Lanes that Metro runs, you pay a toll and you save a bunch of time,” he said. “And you can have more of that.”

That remains a tough sell in sprawled, car-dependent L.A., where public transportation isn’t nearly as abundant or popular as New York. And if congestion pricing stalls or dies (Hochul’s delay order could face legal challenges), what chance does it have here? L.A. Metro’s study concepts could help begin to answer that question.

“Everyone in L.A. hates traffic and this is the one way to help fix it — [but] people don’t like to pay for things,” Vallianatos said. “When these two powerful forces collide, what happens? We don’t exactly know.”

Today’s top stories

A man smiles and points while standing behind a podium

Jerry West dies

Jerry West, Lakers legend and architect of ‘Showtime’ era, dies at 86.
Column: Laker legend Jerry West’s final legacy sadly includes estrangement from Lakers.
How Jerry West became the NBA logo — and why David Stern never admitted to it.

Crime and courts

The Supreme Court upholds FDA’s approval of abortion pills for early pregnancies.
Copper thieves leave 6th Street Bridge — the ‘Ribbon of Light’ — completely in the dark.
Tourists were zip-tied and robbed in an L.A. short-term rental. Should it even have been open?
D.A. notes progress in search for ‘General Hospital’ star Johnny Wactor’s killer.
A grand jury report faults San Francisco for inadequate climate threat planning.
The Supreme Court rejects a California man’s attempt to trademark Trump T-shirts.
Disneyland union files charges against Disney in Mickey button dispute.
Ukrainian family of slain ‘Rust’ filmmaker again sues Alec Baldwin, other producers.

Politics

At Nixon Library, Kennedy Jr. calls for cutting U.S. military budget in half.
‘Not a happy election’: Why this star-studded Hollywood fundraiser is so crucial for Biden.
Californians less likely to vote cite a common reason: They don’t like the presidential candidates.

More big stories

After ‘significant’ vandalism overnight, Cal State L.A. president says encampment must end.
Top manager of California’s largest water supplier accused of sexism and harassment.
‘Just not afraid of humans’: Coyotes plague Mar Vista as neighborhood pets disappear.
L.A. General is closing a mental health clinic. Longtime patients worry about the move.
State regulators identify wildfire neighborhoods targeted for insurance relief.
Swanky airport lounges are arriving at LAX, like this Chase one. But who can get in?
A draft resister, a judge and the moment still binding them after 54 years.
Los Angeles council OKs study of removing police from traffic enforcement.
Occidental trustees vote against divesting from Israel-linked companies.
Now bankrupt, MedMen owes millions to other companies. Meet the cannabis CEO who called them out.
One California city is letting owners sell ADUs, and others may follow. Will it be a housing game-changer?
UCLA commencement goes on amid campus tension over protests, violence and policing.
You can help name L.A.’s newest dinosaur fossil. Just don’t call it Dino McDinoface.

Get unlimited access to the Los Angeles Times. Subscribe here.

Commentary and opinions

Anita Chabria: The abortion pill is safe. Is your uterus?
Editorial: The history, and hypocrisy, of the upside-down American flag.

Today’s great reads

Diane Oppenheimer and Charity Kahn, check out the Inverness Shipwreck.

This California ‘shipwreck,’ beloved but rotting, has got to go, officials say. The Point Reyes has been the backdrop for engagement photos and music videos, for quiet lunch breaks and illicit nighttime beers. People climbed it, trashed it, and, at one point, accidentally set it on fire. It has been beloved and abused. And its days appear to be numbered.

Other great reads

She took over ‘Bridgerton’ as Colin and Penelope moved to the fore: ‘The pressure was immense.’

How can we make this newsletter more useful? Send comments to [email protected].

For your downtime

Coffee at Encino Park from Laidrey and a coffee from Kumquat Coffee in York Park.

Going out

☕Caffeine for you, play time for your kid: 9 L.A. playgrounds near life-giving coffee shops.
🌿Explore the California spot serving up weed country fun the wine country way.
🪩 The Eagles are headed to the Las Vegas Sphere for eight shows this fall.

Staying in

📺 How to watch the 2024 Tony Awards.
📖 ‘Desperately Seeking Susan’ director Susan Seidelman takes stock of her groundbreaking career in her new memoir, “Desperately Seeking Something.”
🧑‍🍳 Here’s a recipe for Spring pea carbonara.
✏️ Get our free daily crossword puzzle, sudoku, word search and arcade games.

And finally ... a great photo

Show us your favorite place in California! We’re running low on submissions. Send us photos that scream California and we may feature them in an edition of Essential California.