Holden, Candidates for Open Council Seats Face Runoffs

In an election with a pitifully low turnout, veteran City Councilman Nate Holden may be the only incumbent forced into a runoff in Tuesday’s primary elections. In other races, political neophytes representing a new generation of Latino leaders battled it out for open council seats on the Eastside and in the San Fernando Valley.

In preliminary election returns, it appeared that no candidate in the Mid-City’s 10th District, the Eastside’s 14th District or the Valley’s 7th District received more than 50% of the vote, the percentage needed to win outright. Instead, it appeared that runoffs are ahead June 8 between Holden and either Scott Suh or Madison Shockley in the 10th District, Nick Pacheco and either Alvin Parra or Victor Griego on the Eastside, and Alex Padilla and Corinne Sanchez in the Valley.

For two open council seats, a host of political novices fought hard to win some name recognition and sway a generally contented public. Organized labor pushed particularly hard in the northeast Valley, though several of the 14 candidates on the Eastside also had individual union support. Endorsements from elected officials were split among the candidates in both races, in which council seats were vacated by the retirement of council power Richard Alatorre and the election of Richard Alarcon to the state Senate in November.

Holden, who faced three challengers, had a particularly tough election season, but the veteran African American politician--known around City Hall as the consummate survivor--has faced and won runoffs before. Suh, who is Korean American, is expected to mount an aggressive campaign from now until June. Suh represents a coalition that is eager to oust the incumbent, who is seeking a final four-year term before being forced into retirement by term limits. Others in the race were Madison Shockley and Marsha Brown.

At his campaign headquarters, Suh said: “What the vote shows is people are ready for change and do not care about the race of the candidate.”

Holden’s challengers played up sexual harassment charges against him and campaign fund-raising concerns. He lashed back with some particularly harsh mailers, then announced that he had won the deathbed endorsement from former Mayor Tom Bradley, particularly surprising since Holden had run against Bradley for mayor and Bradley had twice endorsed Holden’s council opponents.

Holden, who watched returns from home, said: “It’s always a tough race when you run against a big field and against people with lots of money.”

Other council incumbents, Hal Bernson, John Ferraro, Ruth Galanter, Mark Ridley-Thomas and Joel Wachs, appeared to have easily won their way back to City Hall for their final four years under voter-approved term limits. While those council members attended community events and candidates forums and sent out some mail to voters this spring, they did not mount aggressive reelection campaigns.

Tuesday’s dismal voter turnout appeared slightly higher than the 18% recorded by the city clerk’s office in April 1991, one of the lowest turnouts for a primary in the past 20 years.

Mayor Richard Riordan said he was pleased by early returns that showed his favored candidates in two council races leading, although at least one was facing the strong likelihood of a runoff.

“I have a lot of respect for the public,” he said.

The mayor added that if any of the candidates he endorsed face runoffs, he will provide them political and financial support.

“They’re going to have to run a very tough campaign,” he said. “I’ll be there for them.”

As nervous candidates on the Eastside and the Valley spent election day walking precincts and phoning voters, many said the low turnout had a significant effect on the outcomes of those races.

On the Eastside, the primary election was more about personalities than issues. Many candidates attacked Luis Cetina, Victor Griego and Armando Hernandez for carpetbagging. Cetina, however, pointed out that he has lived in the district for more than two years; Griego and Hernandez moved in shortly before the city deadline to run for the office.

Nick Pacheco, a charter reform commissioner with Riordan’s backing, worked the neighborhoods hard and sent out glossy mailers to entice voters. He had campaign offices in Boyle Heights and in Eagle Rock, voter-rich parts of the 14th District.

Just before 11 p.m., Pacheco declared victory. “We talked about the right issues, about reducing crime and bringing jobs to the community,” he said.

The key to winning a runoff in June, Pacheco said, would be “more door-to-door, a basic, solid mail campaign and what I call the mother network.”

Parra, whose stronghold is El Sereno, mounted an aggressive effort four years ago to unseat Alatorre and did surprisingly well then despite being vastly outspent. This time, he faced a greater field of candidates, some well-funded and with high-profile endorsements, but he took an early lead in preliminary results.

“I feel so good,’ he said. “I’m glad our grass-roots campaign paid off. We walked the precincts and got our message out even though we were outspent.”

Griego, a community and political organizer who had the backing of state Assembly Speaker Antonio Villaraigosa and state Senate Majority Leader Richard Polanco, worked the neighborhoods hard. He had trained volunteers in 62 of the 85 precincts calling and visiting potential voters. He sent out community surveys to residents seeking their input and concerns. He then He enlisted the support of hundreds of residents in weekend cleanups where, he boasted, they picked up 10 tons of trash. He insisted Tuesday evening that he will continue the cleanups whether he wins or loses.

Speaking at his packed campaign headquarters, Griego said: “What we saw was 14 candidates trying to get their name out. The two in the runoff are going to have to do more than get their name out, they’re going to have to get their ideas out.”

The others in the race were Jim Beckham, Luis Cetina, Juan Jose Gutierrez, Cathy Molina, Ezequiel “Zeke” Quezada, Juan Jimenez, Sylvia Robledo, Juan Marcos Tirado and write-in hopeful Yolanda Gonzales. Cetina had Alatorre’s backing.

Gutierrez, who runs a nonprofit immigration center in Boyle Heights, was seen as the possible wild card in the race. Along with his veteran political consultant, Rick Taylor, Gutierrez targeted new immigrant voters with mail written mostly in Spanish.

In the Valley, where Padilla and Sanchez led Raul Godinez, Tony Lopez, Ollie McCaulley and Barbara Perkins in money and endorsements, the campaign centered mostly on territorial concerns, such as secession and whether the Valley receives its fair share of city services.

Sanchez, 52, who had a $236,000 campaign war chest and Alarcon’s backing, is an attorney and president of the social service agency El Proyecto del Barrio. Padilla, a 26-year-old legislative aide, was able to match Sanchez in spending with help from Riordan, Assemblyman Tony Cardenas (D-Sylmar) and the county Federation of Labor, which sank $57,000 into an independent mail campaign.

“This is only the first step,” Padilla told 100 supporters. “Believe it or not, we have to begin thinking about June 8.”

Assemblymen Gil Cedillo and Cardenas and county federation head Miguel Contreras were at Padilla’s election party.

“I’m very excited,” Sanchez said of the prospects of facing Padilla in the runoff.

Supporters chanted “Runoff! Runoff! Runoff!” as early returns came in.

*

Times staff writers Matea Gold, Peter Hong, Jean Merl and Nicholas Riccardi and correspondent Richard Winton contributed to this story.